The family of Maddy Cusack says they have been left “heartbroken” after Sheffield United refused to retire her No.8 shirt, despite overwhelming support from fans calling for the tribute.
Cusack, who tragically took her own life on September 20, 2023, aged just 27, remains a cherished figure at Bramall Lane. Her passing sent shockwaves through English football, and ever since, supporters, teammates and the wider game have pushed for the club to immortalise her legacy.
Calls for No.8 to Be Retired
More than 1,200 fans signed a petition urging the Blades to put the number beyond use, with tributes from other clubs setting a strong precedent. Liverpool retired Diogo Jota’s number, Millwall honoured Matija Sarkic, and Swansea City did the same with Besian Idrizaj.
Despite this, Sheffield United have stood firm. The No.8 shirt has not been reissued since Cusack’s death, but the club insists it will remain active in the future. Chief executive Stephen Bettis defended the stance, saying:
“Keeping the number in existence gives a reminder of who has worn it previously and keeps Maddy’s memory alive.”
Family Left in the Dark
Cusack’s family say they only learned of the decision second-hand, discovering it through Fans’ Advisory Board minutes in late 2023 rather than via a direct conversation.
Her mother, Deborah, writing on behalf of the Maddy Cusack Foundation, expressed her devastation:
“I am heartbroken and deeply saddened by the seeming reluctance to retire Maddy’s number eight shirt. This is the deepest mark of respect that can be shown. Other players have been honoured without hesitation, yet we are left having to plead.”
She added that while the shirt remains untouched, its silent absence “feels like disregard rather than tribute.”
Inquest Into Her Death
Cusack’s final months at Sheffield United coincided with the arrival of manager Jonathan Morgan. The inquest, now delayed until January, will examine whether his conduct contributed to her mental health struggles. Morgan, who has since left football, denies wrongdoing and claims he has been unfairly targeted.
Until that hearing concludes, the Blades say no permanent tribute will be confirmed. The club has promised to commemorate the second anniversary of her death during the men’s fixture against Charlton, though the family believes this falls far short of what Maddy deserves.
A Legacy That Deserves More
“Maddy absolutely loved Sheffield United,” Deborah wrote. “She wore her shirt with the utmost pride, showing loyalty and commitment on and off the pitch. To us, retiring her No.8 would be the truest way to celebrate that.”
For fans and family alike, the battle for Sheffield United to honour their fallen midfielder continues — with her iconic No.8 shirt at the heart of the fight.
